When Your Story is No Longer Yours: Five Ways to Tell if an Attack on Your Reputation is Working
Are you prepared to deal with and respond to unwanted attention?
As a young political staffer, I felt like I ruled the world the first day I arrived at an event for my boss. My job as Press Secretary to a Governor was to set the scene, ensure all logistics were in place before his arrival, and – most importantly – make sure the media was writing the story we were laying out for them.
As the last pieces were put in place with meticulous detail, I began making my rounds to the awaiting members of the media to plant the frame of the day in their heads and in their notebooks. Out of nowhere, an out-of-control car came careening through my carefully planned event stage, hit the embankment that was to serve as our backdrop, and went airborne into a train station across the street.
In an instant, my story for the day had been hijacked. Despite my best-laid plans, the headlines that day were dominated by the confused elderly woman who lost control of her car and slammed through the Governor’s media event.
I learned a valuable lesson that day: Your story is not always yours.
Increasingly, issues that were once innocuous and relatively apolitical are becoming fodder for interest groups on either end of the political spectrum. Nonprofits and foundations are finding themselves vulnerable to the kind of reputation attack that was once reserved for the most provocative voices. Environmental organizations under attack by climate change deniers; education organizations attacked by Common Core opponents; public health advocates taken down by Obamacare opponents. These threats are real, and threaten to take away the brand stories that these organizations plan out carefully.
Knowing whether or not an attack will stick is perhaps the trickiest part of mounting a response strategy. Is a response always necessary? Will responding to an attack unnecessarily accelerate a negative story?
- Growing Demand: A sustainable attack on an organization’s reputation will be characterized by a growing chorus of like-minded attackers coming at you from different angles. What started with a single tweet might become a trail of phone calls or a public protest. On the other hand, if an attack comes out of nowhere but doesn’t seem to spread, you can usually chalk it up to a bad day, and nothing more.
- Elevated Exposure: A comment on the official Facebook feed may last forever, but there will be little interest in it beyond the page loyalists. But if the narrative carries itself into a journalist inquiry, you’ve got a problem. The number of real sets of eyes on an attack matters, so gauge your willingness to respond based on who is really paying attention.
- Credible Source: An internet troll is not the same as the New York Times, and the New York Times knows it. Those whose support you covet and value can usually be trusted to recognize fringe when they see it, so don’t always be tempted to respond to that rogue tweet when it’s really your credibility the attacker is after anyway.
- Crisis Catalyst: A real crisis will almost always be characterized by one or more classic catalysts, those wildcard variables that transform a circumstance into a crisis. They are the emotions your audience takes into account in determining whether you’ve done something wrong. Catalysts include things like fear, injustice, immorality and negligence. If any of these emotions are fueling the attack, watch it closely.
- Victim Vulnerability: An attack can come from a variety of angles, but is almost always dependent on someone being wronged in some way, either real or imagined. If that victim is a member of a traditionally vulnerable population – children, elderly, people with disabilities, etc. – you’ve got a problem on your hands.
The most frightening part of a reputation attack is that you don’t have to have actually done anything wrong for the attack to be impactful. These five indicators can act as a good barometer when planning out crisis scenarios or gauging the appropriateness of hitting back.
RELATED ON STORYTELLING FOR GOOD
Related, on Storytelling for Good
The Storytellers Formerly Known as the Audience
- 1 Saved
What Are Archetypes and How Do I Use Them in Storytelling? Part II
- 2 Saved
5 Stories Nonprofits Should Be Telling on Social Media
- 1 Comment
- 12 Saved
The Science of Storytelling, Part 1: Help Your Audience Understand Cause and Effect
- 1 Saved
Tell Donors the Right Story With Your Annual Report
- 1 Comment
- 1 Saved
A Single Story Does Not Change the World
- 3 Saved